Governance Policy Manual Checklist for Associations and Nonprofits
The policy manual holds the operating rules the board can change by its own vote. Here is what a complete manual covers and how to keep it current.
Last reviewed November 2026.
The test for every policy
Each policy should be written, board-adopted, dated, consistent with the bylaws, and actually followed. Bylaws set the structure; policies carry it out and are easier to change. A useful rule of thumb: anything expected to change within a few years belongs in policy, not the bylaws. Where a policy conflicts with the bylaws, the bylaws generally control.
Required, asked about, or optional
Sort each policy into one of three groups. Some carry out legal obligations under Colorado nonprofit law and your own bylaws, such as members’ records inspection rights. Some answer questions Form 990 asks, which are public but not legally required. The rest are good practice. Label each policy so the board knows which is which.
Policies Form 990 asks about
Tax-exempt associations that file IRS Form 990 answer governance questions in Part VI. The form notes these policies are not required by the Internal Revenue Code, but the answers are public. It asks whether the organization:
- Has a written conflict of interest policy, requires annual disclosure, and monitors and enforces it.
- Has a written whistleblower policy and a document retention and destruction policy.
- Sets executive pay through independent review, comparability data, and a contemporaneous record.
- Documents board and committee meetings, and gives the board a copy of the Form 990 before filing.
What else belongs in the manual
- Antitrust and legal risk. An antitrust policy, rules for member surveys and data, uniform admission and discipline procedures, confidentiality, and lobbying and political activity.
- Board operations. Job descriptions, a code of conduct, orientation and annual training, committee charters, a minutes standard, and chief staff executive evaluation and succession.
- Financial controls. Budget and variance reporting, reserves and investments, expense reimbursement, signature limits, segregation of duties, and audit or review.
- Conduct and people. Anti-harassment with a reporting channel, volunteer removal consistent with the bylaws, data privacy and cybersecurity, and records access that matches members’ inspection rights under Colorado law.
For REALTOR® associations, NAR’s Governance Guide for Association Executives (October 2019 edition) also lists policies such as consent to serve, fraud prevention, HR and employment practices, succession planning, portability of membership records, and safety.
Keep it current
Show each policy’s adoption date, last review date, owner (the officer, committee, or staff role responsible for it), and review interval. Conflict of interest disclosures are annual; set a cycle for the rest. Review the full manual on a fixed cycle, archive superseded versions, and have directors acknowledge the manual each year.
Need a manual drafted or updated?
We draft and update governance and policy manuals for REALTOR® associations, MLSs, and other professional trade associations. Schedule a Consultation or send a preliminary inquiry.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between bylaws and a policy manual?
Bylaws set the association’s structure and take a formal amendment process to change. Policies are adopted by the board to carry out the bylaws and are easier to update, but they must stay consistent with the bylaws.
Does the IRS require a conflict of interest policy?
Form 990 says the policies it asks about in that section are not required by the Internal Revenue Code. But the form asks whether the organization has one, and the answer is part of a public return.
How often should a governance policy manual be reviewed?
On a fixed cycle, and after any bylaw change, merger, or new law. Each policy should show when it was last reviewed.
Should a policy manual include antitrust guidelines?
For trade and professional associations whose members compete, yes. The FTC notes that forming a trade association does not shield competitors’ joint activities from antitrust scrutiny.
Get the full one-page checklist
Free one-page Governance Policy Manual Checklist
The full one-page checklist covers the policies Form 990 asks about, antitrust and legal risk, board operations, financial controls, conduct and privacy, NAR’s suggested policies for REALTOR® associations, and manual upkeep.
Related
Association & nonprofit counsel · Schedule a consultation · Submit an inquiry · All free checklists
Need a governance policy manual?
Send a preliminary inquiry or schedule a consultation to talk through a manual for your association.