Earnest Money Disputes in Colorado: A Checklist for Buyers and Sellers
When a Colorado home deal ends, the deposit should not become a second fight. Here is how buyers and sellers can avoid an earnest money dispute, and what happens if they cannot agree.
Last reviewed November 2026.
Avoid the dispute
Work from the final signed contract, including every counterproposal and amendment. Calendar every deadline in it. Give termination notices in writing, on time, and the way the contract requires. Keep proof of delivery for every notice. Most earnest money disputes turn on whether a notice was timely and proper.
Know who holds the money
Your signed contract names the earnest money holder. It is usually the title company, though a brokerage firm can also hold it. The holder pays out only as the contract allows, so a signed release has to reach that holder. Do not expect the holder to decide who is right. It will not.
How the money gets released
Expect a release only on signed written instructions from both buyer and seller, or a court order. After a proper termination, the other party generally has three days after receiving the Earnest Money Release form to sign it, or they are in default.
A claim is not a release. A claim is one side saying the money belongs to it, for example a seller saying the buyer missed a deadline. A release is a written instruction, signed by both buyer and seller, telling the holder who gets paid. A claim alone does not move the money. Under the standard contract, refusing to sign a release on time is a default unless the refusing side is entitled to the money because the other side defaulted. When there is a dispute, the holder does not have to release the money to either side.
Sellers: refusing to sign a release you owe, as leverage, can put you in default.
Buyers: a missed deadline can cost the deposit even when your reason was good.
If you cannot agree
- Expect mediation first. The standard contract calls for it before a lawsuit.
- Know the holder’s options. It may keep holding the money, or deposit it with a court and recover its court costs and attorney fees for doing so.
- If there is a dispute, the holder may give notice and return the money to the buyer unless it receives a copy of a lawsuit within 120 days of that notice.
- Ask whether small claims court is an option for the amount at stake.
- Know that the standard contract requires a court or arbitrator to award the winning side its reasonable costs and attorney fees.
- Weigh the math: the size of the deposit against time, fees, and a house that may be tied up.
When to get help from your REALTOR® or an attorney
Talk to your REALTOR® or a Colorado real estate attorney before you send or refuse a termination notice, before a deadline you may miss, and before you refuse to sign a release. Questions about a termination notice or a release? Schedule a 30-minute Virtual Consultation or send a preliminary inquiry. See also our Colorado homebuyer checklist and Colorado home seller checklist.
For REALTORS®: share this with your buyers
REALTORS® can point buyer clients to this page and the free checklist. When a buyer’s question calls for legal analysis, we work alongside you, not in place of you. For your firm’s own compliance questions, see the Brokerage Firm Monthly Retainer Program and our broker FAQs.
Frequently asked questions
Who usually holds earnest money in a Colorado home purchase?
The holder named in your signed contract. It is usually the title company, though a brokerage firm can also hold it. The holder will not decide who is right.
How is earnest money released?
Expect a release only on signed written instructions from both buyer and seller, or a court order. After a proper termination, the other party generally has three days after receiving the Earnest Money Release form to sign it, or they are in default.
What if we cannot agree on who gets the deposit?
The standard contract calls for mediation before a lawsuit. The holder may keep holding the money, or deposit it with a court and recover its court costs and attorney fees for doing so. The holder may also give notice and return the money to the buyer unless it receives a copy of a lawsuit within 120 days of that notice.
Can a missed deadline cost a buyer the deposit?
Yes. A missed deadline can cost the deposit even when the buyer's reason was good. Sellers who refuse to sign a release they owe, as leverage, can be put in default.
Get the full one-page checklist
Free one-page Earnest Money Disputes Checklist
The full one-page checklist covers how to avoid a dispute, who holds the deposit, how the money is released, what happens if you cannot agree, and when to get help.
Related
Legal help for real estate consumers · Schedule a consultation · Submit an inquiry · All free checklists
Questions about a termination notice or a release?
Talk to your REALTOR® or a Colorado real estate attorney before you send or sign anything.